Mock Trial: Bakke v. University of Cal

Bakke v. University of California

Ladies and gentlemen of the court,

    In Bakke v. University of California, Allan Bakke was twice turned down for admission to medical school, not because he was unqualified, but because the university used a racial quota system to reserve seats only for minority applicants. Addressing historical inequality is a worthwhile goal, but laws like this one lead to new injustices. The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment forbid discrimination on the basis of race against anybody. Due to his race, Mr. Bakke, a competent applicant with better academic qualifications than some of those admitted, was turned away. This is unjust exclusion, not variety.

    However, the University of California's approach divides rather than aims to empower. It is possible to achieve diversity and opportunity without going against the legal concept that all people, regardless of color, are equal. Policies must be inclusive, not divisive. 

    Supporting minority students can be done in more effective ways. In order to give African Americans access to high-quality education throughout periods of exclusion, historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) were founded. These institutions continue to be essential for promoting Black achievement and provide a nurturing environment where students can flourish both professionally and socially. Without infringing upon the rights of others, students of color can contribute to closing educational inequities by supporting and attending these schools.

    All in all, it's better to be with your people. This type of education is good and you think you want to go to this school but you would be more comfortable and happier there. University of California is a prestigious and very respected school, we don’t need this case bringing their name down.

    I urge this court to decide in Mr. Bakke's favor. One type of discrimination cannot be substituted for another in the context of promoting fairness. Let's make sure that our educational system supports the basic justice that is a foundation of American democracy, offers opportunity, and honors merit.

                                                                                                                                 Thank you.